Death to Aggregators
Tuesday, April 27, 2004
Frank Steele thinks that aggregators should be subsumed into browsers
I’ve got a fair amount of sympathy for what he says. Syndication is about browsing, so why not do it in the browser?
The case is even more persuasive because browsing in current aggregators generally sucks – NNW launches new browser instances, nothing in windows blocks popups and so on and so forth.
But, having said that, Mozilla/Firefox has shown that the world is moving away from swiss army knife browsers. Feed browsing (for me and presumably a big chunk of other people) is a different kind of consumption experience than normal web browsing. The difference is subtle but it’s there. If I wanted to read feeds in my browser I could use bloglines or amphetadesk, but I don’t.
I’d hope that rather than vanishing, desktop aggregators will raise their game when it comes to the browsing experience.
Permanent link
with
CVS Sucks
Tuesday, April 27, 2004
I should have set up my project as two separate projects in a solution, one for the UI and a lib for the core code.
Having made this great realization, I’m screwed now in terms of CVS ‘cause I basically have to delete everything and start again, losing all my version histories.
We use Perforce at work which, for all its shortcomings, handles this case rather well.
I suppose there’s always that hope that I’ve missed something because of my weak CVS skills but google suggests otherwise.
Permanent link
with
Some sage advice
Sunday, April 25, 2004
Hmm, so a post which was really nothing more than a bit of a whinge, actually got me some really good advice
It hadn’t really occurred to me that people might want to hack the code to a project that hadn’t even released anything yet. In fact truth be told I hadn’t considered that there would ever be a development community any bigger than my code, Paul’s graphics and Phil’s constant nagging !
But, in for a penny, in for a pound. The code is now marginally better commented and there are instructions on how to build it
As for test cases, currently they consist of subscribing to every feed that even slightly interests me. I should put something more structured in place, but first I have to work out why Russell Beatie’s large but otherwise uncomplicated-appearing feed won’t parse.
While you wait however, go wild with the code, whoever you may be.
Permanent link
with
Release early, release often?
Friday, April 23, 2004
So FeedThing is now good enough to be the only aggregator I use. It’s responsive and it uses roughly 10% if the memory of .NET news readers such as Sauce Reader.
The overwhelming tempation is to release a version. Isn’t that what you’re supposed to do in the wild and wooly world of open source?
What worries me is that I think that probably only works if you have no competitors. Or maybe if you have no free competitors.
Objectively speaking, if I downloaded FeedThing in its current state, I’d not bother with it again (I know this by the pile of dead aggregators in my recycle bin). The biggest weakness is adding feeds. No auto discovery, no integration of any sort with the browser.
If I release early, even if I am lucky enough to come to people’s attention, I am likely to drive them straight away, never to return.
PulpFiction is in the same position as me. Trying to release a new aggreagor against established competition. Now OK, their offering is commercial, but even still I can’t help thinking that they’ve done the right thing by waiting until they are feature complete before releasing a version.
Which is all so tedious. Release early, release often offers so much more instant gratification.
Permanent link
with
How to write an aggregator
Tuesday, April 20, 2004
This is a list of resources which are useful when building an RSS/Atom aggregator. I found them useful when building FeedThing, maybe other people will too.
Expect this list to grow.
Things That FeedThing Does Correctly
Things That Still Need Work in FeedThing
How to Explain an Aggregator
Permanent link
with
Timely reminder
Monday, April 19, 2004
Must remember this post when it comes to stripping and making safe the content in FeedThing.
Interestingly, the body of that article exposes a bug which actually breaks the current unsafe display code, so there’s two lessons for the price of one.
Permanent link
with
Aggregation improvements
Saturday, April 17, 2004
I think it’s cause I started writing an aggregator , but Phil has helpfully been off and started reviewing the competition.
Something that struck me though is that none of the aggregators he looked at supported pop-up blocking.
This was something I had planned from day one (admittedly with no real clue how to do it ;-). However it looks very much like I won’t have to bother now.
For all its supposed faults Windows XP SP2 seems like it will, at a stroke, improve all the IE embedding desktop aggregators out there.
Here’s the big step forward Phil was looking for, without anyone having to do anything.
Permanent link
with
Back in the blogging spirit
Thursday, April 15, 2004
I abandoned my last blog and switched exclusively to livejournal about 3 months in. I think that was the right thing to do, the mix of techy bullshit and photos of my daughter was a strange one and something had to give.
However every now and again I feel like I should be ranting about something or other and livejournal isn’t the place to do it.
So here’s the plan: livejournal for my life, xurble.org for my geek stuff.
Is there room for both? I guess we’ll find out.
Permanent link
with
About
Thursday, April 01, 2004
Gareth Simpson entered a career in software engineering via the usual route of studies in modern languages, politics and philosophy.
He lives in Burbank, California with his partner Emma and his daughter Madeline.
All opinions are those of the author, and are in all likelihood wrong.
Other Places
Permanent link
with
Welcome
Thursday, April 01, 2004
You have reached the personal website of Gareth Simpson.
I am a UK based Software Engineer with the usual background in Politics and Philosophy.
This site contains things of mine that need a home on the internet such as:
My small coding projects:
- Grabbr - A screenshotting tool that uploads to flickr
- iChat for Miranda - A iChat/Rendezvous chat plugin for the Miranda Instant Messenger
- iScrobbler for Windows - An Audioscrobbler plugin for iTunes
- FeedThing - A simple but fast windows RSS aggregator
- Motherload - A small app for loading MP3 players from iTunes in a shuffle-esque style.
- jTechnorati - Some java classes for using the Techorati API
- jTextile - A java 1.3 implementation of the Textile HTML formatting library
- Greasemonkey Scripts - Little hacks to make the web nicer
My
weblog wherein you will find:
- Development notes on my projects
- Rants about programming
- Rants about politics
- Other random things
Permanent link
with
